I promised a follow-up on my neighbor’s roofing job so here it is. In my last post I used the analogy of a box of Cracker Jacks (referring to the surprises) and this job has been nothing but a surprise. We left off last with Josh, Bill & Ted frantically tarping the roof in a downpour with upside down smiles. We pick up today with a new surprise.

Exposing the Mansard hip

The fellas decided to start work on the hip, fascia and soffit of the roof apparently to avoid some of the exposure to the rain, but maybe also because they needed to deal with the area where the hip meets the top part of the roof. The knuckleheads who had put on the last roof had wrapped the top edge right over the hip. No trim board – nothing. Anyway, as the guys peeled away the old fascia, they saw a lot of rot. Most of the boards that hold the gently curving boards that create the Mansard contour were either totally or in part rotted. These will all need new boards “sistered” to them so the new fascia boards will stay in place.

Peeling off the Mansard hip shingles and sheeting

On this morning (I should have kept an exact timeline because the weather forced a lot of stops and starts – but I’m not that organized) Bill & Ted found that the sheating, although quite rotten, was no rose garden. Trying to pull off 135 year old wood while standing on a 12 inch platform is not fun. No real weight can be put on the board their feet are on as it is just nailed into old rotten wood.

Plaster and lath

The backside of the plaster and lath wall can be seen here nicely. They could have easily kicked right through to the rental unit if they had wanted. It’s really interesting to see how simple a house really is. We take them for granted when we’re inside and dry, but there’s very little real estate between us and a good bit of weather.

Josh's foot goes through the sheeting.

Josh’s foot passed through the sheeting somewhere near the chimney and it is decided that it needs to be completely replaced. The job is now 3-4 times bigger than it started. Hmmm, those clouds are looking dark aren’t they???

These poor guys got held up by rain and lots of set backs. In order to close up the gaping hole in the roof they had to work well after dusk by work light in order to get all the new sheeting on. The cold beer must’ve tasted pretty good that night.

The 1st row of felt paper goes on.

I think it’s actually starting to rain here – but the guys aren’t phased at this point. They’re rolling out the 1st line of felt paper. The outermost edge is a weather guard that is more durable than the subsequent rows. Mainly this protects the edge as it gets the most wear and the most weather.

Almost done with the felt paper.

Josh lays down on the job for a while as he tacks the felt paper up. You can see the sheen on the wood from the rain. It’s pretty slippery up there. Almost ready for the shingles – another day…

The first side gets shingles!

Josh’s crew nears the home stretch (for the top of the roof anyway) as they come around the second side with the shingles. Once the entire roof is covered they will still need to come back and do ridge vents. Next is the flashing on the chimney.

Josh flashes around the chimney.

An 8 inch or so piece of aluminum wraps around the chimney and then a row of shingles gets tacked snugly around it to keep the water out. Before he is done, Josh will have to use some heavy duty caulk and seal the top edge under the rubber flaps shown.

The Mansard hip gets insulation.

I almost forgot this picture. The hip is now totally exposed and this has given the guys the opportunity to insulate. This has all been a lot of work for them, but what a payoff the new roof and insulation will be. More to come…

Today I had the privilege of having a birds-eye-view of my neighbor (I’ll refer to him as Josh to protect his anonymity) roofing his own house. Josh purchased his home a couple years ago in less than perfect condition and has gone on to prove that this can often be a great way to enter an otherwise expensive market. Obviously one must be armed with a first hand knowledge of carpentry and home improvement or enough money to pay someone else – which as many of us know can sometimes end up worse than if we had just done it ourselves.

Josh perches precariously on a ladder

Josh has been slowly turning an ugly duckling into a bonafide gem. His latest effort is ambitious – a new roof. Keep in mind that our homes (they were probably built by the same builder and are certainly the same vintage) are roughly 135 years old. Pretty much every job is like a box of Cracker Jacks. There’s a surprise in there somewhere… and this project was no exception. I was able to stick my head out my kitchen window and monitor progress which I’m sure Josh appreciated immensely. I tried to lighten the dreariness of the day the best way I knew how – by being a Wisenheimer. At first I thought Josh was telling me I was “#1″ but quickly realized he was destined for victory [over the roof].

Josh & George install scaffolding

Josh was being helped today by his friends Bill & Ted. (Their names have also been changed to protect their anonymity.) Here they are installing scaffolding so they don’t fall off the roof as they remove the old shingles. I’m only mildly scared of heights, but this was making me quite nervous. Actually, I’m not nearly as scared of heights as I am of falling to my death – so it’s really all about security for me. Clearly Josh, Bill & Ted do not share this fear.

Josh harnesses to the chimney

There was some level of safety exercised however. Josh lashed the fellas to the 135 year old chimney with climbing gear. I thought this was a great idea and it made me feel much better until I remembered the old Warner Bros cartoons where Wiley Coyote would similarly lash himself to a tree or a rock outcropping only to fall to the canyon floor followed by the large, heavy object to make two successive poofs of dust, one for Wiley and the other, slightly larger poof for the very heavy object that usually pushed him 10 ft or so into the Earth’s crust. Seriously though, who doesn’t get an audible chuckle from the image of Wiley Coyote walking away, disgruntled, with his mid-section bobbing like an accordion? Anyway, Ted is beginning the process of prying off the old shingles and removing the nails. This is a filthy, hard job and it makes a BIG mess.

Josh, Bill & Ted start making progress as the rain starts

The guys really got down to business peeling off the shingles. This is when Josh found the surprise in the Cracker Jacks. Much of the roof sheating and fascia was practically dust on the top side. He had previously checked the condition from the attic and it looked great – but the top side wouldn’t likely hold nails any longer. He’s also planning on rebuilding a lot of the Mansard hip (the steeply sloped sides). As you can see, Josh’s job just got a lot bigger, and a lot more expensive. His house is getting an entirely new roof.

Josh inspects his 135 year old roof sheating

Josh is inspecting his antique roof sheating. Look closely at the veins in his forehead as he comes to terms with the fact that he is now going to have to hoist large sheets of plywood up onto his roof. Don’t forget he has to pry all this old wood off first which will leave the inside of his house open to the elements until he can seal it back up. Thankfully, his tenant lives on the second floor.

Josh & Bill brave the Tempest

Suddenly, without warning (except for the weather report) the rain really started coming down. Who would have thought – two surprises in one box of Cracker Jacks! Luckily I had a huge tarp to add to Josh’s collection and the guys frantically started to cover up the house. This was no easy job. Check out the driving rain and the look of grit determination on Bill’s face. They got it covered up in short time and now it looks like some of the houses from back home in the Ozark Mountains.

A hairnet for the house

The only problem with the tarps is that they are like big sails up there on the roof. They all have to be tacked down with furring strips. The surface was then so slippery that they had to tack in strips of wood like a ladder to climb up and down. It’s like a big residential rubber.

Bill & Ted clean up the mess

This kind of job makes a nasty mess. The little grit from the old shingles gets everywhere and the material is heavy and cumbersome. It would be interesting if someone could come up with use for all the old shingles in the world.

More on this adventure as it unfolds.